Skip to main content
Category

Pluralism

The Danger of False Positives

By Christian Living, Discipleship, Faithfulness, Grace, Liberalism, Peace, Pluralism, Truth, Uncategorized No Comments

Though it’s been several years ago now, I still remember one of the more exciting trips to St. Jude Hospital with my son during his battle with childhood leukemia. Back in those days we lived in Mobile, Alabama, requiring us to fly for weekly chemotherapy in Memphis. Over a three-year period, we made 128 consecutive trips in order to jumpstart and protect my son’s remission from cancer.

While passing through security on our return trip, a Ziploc bag containing a bottle of medication tested positive for a small amount of glycerin, which can be used to make explosives. Quickly, TSA workers surrounded us with a bomb sniffing dog. They pulled us aside and began a battery of tests. Thankfully, our faces were familiar and employees recognized us. My son’s glistening, bald head gave away our recent trip to the hospital

Still, it was only after several minutes of awkward suspicion and investigation that we were allowed to pass through the security checkpoint. Turns out it was a false positive caused by a melting icepack that was cooling the medication. The whole ordeal got me to thinking about the misleading consequences of false impressions, which can leave us happy or scared depending on what they report.

For example, you might be overjoyed initially only to be disappointed later if a pregnancy test falsely reveals that the child you’ve prayed for is on the way. Or, you might be immediately frightened when airport security suspects foul play as you travel, even if you are able to laugh about it afterward. The problem, though, is that neither reaction is trustworthy. False positives are dangerous because they invite us to live outside of reality based upon something that is not true.

Unfortunately, American Christianity has its share of false positives. Many Bible teachers are anxious to assure their listeners that God’s primary goal is our personal happiness. Others insist that hell cannot be real because a loving God would never allow anyone to go there. Notions of remaining in sin while following Jesus is the most damning false positive of all. These untruthful assertions are usually received with enthusiasm, but they create a false narrative about WHO Jesus is and WHAT He came to do.

The historical reality that God would sacrifice His Son to deal with our sin problem is insulting to some and downright barbaric to others. Retired Methodist theologian, William Willimon, fairly critiqued, “If you listen to much of our preaching, you get the impression that Jesus was some sort of itinerant therapist who, for free, traveled about helping people feel better.”

Thankfully, Jesus had a way of turning our temporal ambitions on their head in order to focus on what we really need. Take, for example, the familiar story of Jesus healing the paralytic (Matt. 9:1-8). Without question, this man’s burdens were significant. He could not walk, eat, or bathe without the help of others and, by consequence, he was an outcast in society. We can hardly blame his friends for attempting to help him.

Rather than heal the man immediately, though, Jesus said to him, “Take courage, son; your sins are forgiven (Matt. 9:2).” By doing so, Jesus reminded us that our temporal burdens are merely symptoms of our greatest needs. He is not a Savior who came to improve the quality of our lives (though He often does), but who came to forgive our sins. Yet, popular false positives deceive us into believing that God solving our earthly problems is more important than His addressing our eternal condition.

Because the scribes accused Jesus of blasphemy (Matt. 9:3), He immediately exposed their blindness with a piercing question. Is it easier to say, “Your sins are forgiven,” or “Get up, and walk (Matt. 9:5)?” Amazingly, Jesus chose to heal the paralytic in order to demonstrate His authority to forgive sins, not distract from it (Matt. 9:6). The real goal was much bigger than the man’s physical healing. In fact, had Jesus only forgiven the paralytic’s transgressions it would have solved his greatest threat.

I am not suggesting that we should not seek God’s intervention when trials come. During my son’s fight against cancer, I repeatedly begged the Lord to heal him. Yet, we often equate our present comforts as an indicator of our eternal health. Our desperation for temporary relief from earthly troubles often far exceeds our concern about spiritual matters. Even worse, we sometimes reduce God’s faithfulness to His meeting our immediate needs.

God, show me a miracle and prove you’re real.

God, answer this prayer and prove you’re real.

God, give me what I want and prove you’re real.

God, heal me and prove you’re real.

God, open this door and prove you’re real

Tragically, expressions of temporary grace often grip us more than eternal realities. Our need for forgiveness, though, is so urgent that we ought to be willing to lose this life entirely in order to receive it from Christ (Matt. 16:24-27). Nothing is more necessary, and nothing is more remarkable than the glorious truth that Jesus would come to seek and to save the lost!

Adam B. Dooley
November 29, 2024

Pope Francis and the Uncertain Sound of Pluralism

By Pluralism No Comments

Pope Francis and the Uncertain Sound of Pluralism

Pope Francis recently dropped quite a theological bombshell at an interreligious youth gathering in Singapore by claiming that “all religions are paths to God.” He went on to explain that religions are like languages seeking to express the divine. “There is only one God,” the pontiff stated, “and each of us has a language, so to speak, in order to arrive at God. Sihk, Muslim, Hindu, Christian. There are different paths. Understand?”

Unfortunately, this is not the first time Pope Francis has dipped his toe in the waters of religious pluralism. Back in 2022, at a similar meeting in Kazakhstan, the leader of the world’s 1.3 billion Catholics caused similar confusion when he addressed the 7th Congress of Leaders of World and Traditional Religions as a united “fraternity” made up of “children of the same heaven . . . journeying toward the same heavenly goal.” By doing so, this pope placed himself in direct opposition to the faith once and for all handed down to the saints (Jude 1:3), and consequently, the preaching of the Savior he claims to represent.

But why should followers of Christ who are not Catholic care about sloppy statements like these? As much as we might like to pretend that only our friends in Rome must worry about such errant theology, the reality is that Protestants are drinking the same pluralistic poison. According to a 2022 LifeWay Study, almost six out of ten evangelicals agree with the statement, “God accepts the worship of all religions, including Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.” Either ignorance of or apathy for Scripture seems to be the most common hermeneutic today.

As God prepared ancient Israel to birth the Messiah, He repeatedly admonished them regarding his exclusivity (Deut. 6:4-5) even as He warned them about the danger of acknowledging false gods (Joshua 23:16). These exclusions were so important that God codified them within His commandments, restricting who (Ex. 20:3) and how (Ex. 20:4-5) His people worshipped. The Lord even declared the customs of false religions as a “delusion” to be rejected because pagan idols will perish with the earth (Jer. 10:6-18). Ultimately, both Israel and Judah succumbed to the pluralistic fodder of their day and faced exile from their land as a result.

When Jesus stepped on to the scene as the fulfillment of Messianic prophecy, He maintained that there is a single path to heaven by preaching an exclusive gospel. Though His invitation was open to all people from all walks of life, the path of redemption was singular rather than multifaceted. Our Savior unapologetically declared, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father but through Me. (John 14:6)”

Jesus further cautioned, “The gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and there are many who enter through it (Matt. 7:13b).” The popular path of the majority, which insists that all religions are viable paths to God, leads to eternal punishment. On this road you can believe anything, or you can believe nothing, usually to the applause of the masses. It is the path of least resistance, without boundaries or restrictions. Just live your truth. Just chart your own course. Just do whatever feels right.

By contrast, the steps toward eternal life “enter through the narrow gate,” (Matt. 7:13a) because according to Christ “the gate is small and the way is narrow that leads to life, and there are few who find it (Matt. 7:14).” This way of living limits our devotion solely to the person of Jesus. He is not a good way to heaven, or even the best way. HE IS THE ONLY WAY. The exclusivity of Jesus Christ exposes all other religions as woefully impotent and blindly deceptive.

Clarity like this does not prevent any who desire to walk the path of righteousness from doing so. To the contrary, it points to the true way of salvation for those sincerely seeking to live according to the truth. The problem is not in the clear directive of Scripture, but in our fallen tendency to compromise ideas that are right in order to accommodate those which are wrong. Thus, “few” will find these words helpful, despite their reliability.

The pope’s muddy language, even if unintentionally, leads people down the wrong path, away from God. Thankfully, the Bible’s authors make plain what some religious leaders today do not. “There is salvation in no one else,” says Luke, “for there is no other name under heaven that has been given among men by which we must be saved (Acts 4:12).” The Apostle Paul echoed the same reality, “For there is one God, and one mediator also between God and men, the man Christ Jesus (1 Tim. 2:5).” Ultimately, since the name of Jesus is above every other name, every knee will bow and every tongue will confess that Jesus is Lord to the glory of God the Father (Phil. 2:9-11).